Portland, OR

The land-fraud 'king' whose 1904 Portland trial ended with no defense witnesses

Stephen Puter's trial at the Pioneer Courthouse opened 122 years ago, and his conviction and confession helped unravel Oregon's land-fraud ring.

Pioneer Courthouse in Portland, Oregon
File photo: M.O. Stevens via Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 3.0
By Published

When the government finished presenting its case against Stephen Puter in a Portland federal courtroom in 1904, his defense team did something striking: it rested without calling a single witness.

According to the Oregon Encyclopedia, the evidence against Puter and his co-defendants was simply too overwhelming to answer.

Puter's trial opened at the Pioneer Courthouse on November 23, 1904, 122 years ago.

He had styled himself the "King of the Oregon Land Fraud Ring."

Within weeks he was a convicted felon.

Before the decade was out, his testimony had helped send a sitting U.S. senator to a guilty verdict.

A career that began in 1875

According to the Oregon Encyclopedia, Puter was born January 6, 1857.

His criminal career began in 1875, after he helped a U.S. surveyor in California subdivide townships near his family's Humboldt County homestead.

When the townships opened for settlement, he recruited men to file fraudulent homestead claims and sold them to a lumber company.

Over the next three decades, the encyclopedia says, he kept acquiring and selling fraudulent patents, often bribing federal officials to get them approved.

The scheme exploited the homestead laws, which were meant to put public land into the hands of proven settlers.

Speculators filed false claims, and in some cases the homesteaders' names were entirely fictitious.

Once the patents were approved, they were sold to lumber and livestock companies.

"By this means," the Oregon Encyclopedia writes, great tracts of valuable timber and grazing land were stolen from the American public.

The claims near Detroit

The case that caught up with Puter began in 1900.

He and his partner, Horace G. McKinley, filed claims in Township 11-7, near Detroit, Oregon.

The township was hard to reach, so Puter assumed inspections would be unlikely.

Federal officials did inspect it, twice, but Puter bribed both to write favorable reports.

The applications still stalled at the General Land Office.

In February 1902, Puter went to Washington, D.C., and paid Senator John H. Mitchell $2,000 to speed them along.

The patents were approved days later.

The investigation itself grew out of two letters, according to the encyclopedia.

One, from a Catholic priest, warned Interior Secretary Ethan A. Hitchcock of frauds in Tillamook.

Inspector Alfred A. Greene was assigned to look into it, and his work led him to Puter.

A second letter, from an Arizona lawyer, alleged a separate conspiracy by land speculators in California and Arizona.

A federal grand jury indicted Puter and McKinley in 1903.

Puter managed to delay his trial for several months by sending accomplices into hiding, among them his mistress, Emma Watson.

Trial and a confession

The trial finally began on November 23, 1904.

Francis J. Heney, a special assistant to the U.S. attorney general, presented the government's case over about two weeks.

The jury found Puter, McKinley and Watson guilty, and Puter's conviction is dated December 7, 1904.

Puter then made a full confession to the grand jury, admitting the bribe to Senator Mitchell.

The attorney general was reluctant to prosecute a senator on the word of a convicted criminal, so Puter helped recruit other witnesses.

One was a lumber company representative who had bribed Mitchell with a check.

The Portland grand jury eventually indicted nearly one hundred people, the encyclopedia says, including Mitchell, U.S. District Attorney John Hall, Congressman John N. Williamson and former General Land Office commissioner Binger Hermann.

Mitchell's trial came during the summer of 1905, while crowds were attending the Lewis and Clark Centennial Exposition.

He was then in his fourth Senate term and was, in the encyclopedia's words, "arguably the most powerful politician in the state."

The jury convicted him on July 3 after his own law partner and private secretary testified against him.

A chase, an escape and a book

Puter's own troubles were not over.

Learning he was under investigation for other frauds, he fled to Boston.

There, in March 1906, Secret Service detective William J. Burns caught him.

Puter then made what the encyclopedia calls a dramatic escape on a crowded street in front of the Fenway post office and made his way back to California.

An associate betrayed him to local police, and he was sentenced to two years in the Multnomah County jail.

In jail he worked with Horace Stevens, a former General Land Office clerk, on an account of his exploits.

The result, Looters of the Public Domain, was, in the Oregon Encyclopedia's assessment, "the definitive history of the Oregon Land Frauds for more than a century."

On Heney's recommendation, President Theodore Roosevelt pardoned Puter on December 31, 1907.

He left jail a week later, on his fifty-first birthday.

He died May 10, 1931.

What the trials changed

The fallout was uneven.

Williamson was convicted only at a third trial, in January 1906, after two juries failed to agree, but the U.S. Supreme Court later overturned his conviction.

Mitchell died before his appeal could be heard.

Hall was found guilty in 1908, and Hermann's 1910 trial ended in a jury deadlocked by a single holdout.

Hall and another figure in the case, Franklin P. Mays, were later pardoned by President William Howard Taft.

Roosevelt alleged that was part of a deal to deny him the 1912 Republican nomination.

Still, the scandals had real effects.

In 1905, Congress amended the land laws and moved control of the nation's forests from the General Land Office to the U.S. Forest Service.

Harry Lane won election as Portland mayor that year as the scandals helped Oregon Democrats.

The Oregon Encyclopedia concludes that with Mitchell's conviction, "an echo of the Gilded Age drew to a close and the era of the Progressives began."

See more local news from us on GoogleAdd The Neighborhood Register as a preferred source to see more of our stories in Google's Top Stories.

This story was written with AI assistance from the public sources listed above. Spot an error? Email [email protected].